Orbit eTOG Listing Service: RFC-17 My Sister's Cat
Description: Katy told me that I should add a TOG for her cat, Hubert. Although certain TOGs like T+005F and T+0093 already apply to him, I would consider adding GUY WHO IS HUBERT. But I would not want to pollute the database with personal TOGs if others did not see value in them.
!!closed!!
Comments:
- Against this due to slippery slope — soon enough everyone's cat will be on the prestigious eTOG Listing Service, soiling its creditability
- Against, even though I posted the RFC. Basically same reason
- i would allow "guy who is a cat" which would allow a consolidation of everyone's cat
- for, because it would be funny
- see t+008d
- Agree, because it's too late now I guess
- also aside, I'm not sure t+93 applies to a literal cat
- Last commenter, do you know about jokes?
- no
- Against, for the same reason as first two commenters. Robs TOG catalog of generality.
- Resolved by the deprecation of T+00D8.
Home